by Molly Ivors
No, I'm not talking about the denizens of The Corner, who, are, after all, in Thers's column to abuse. I'm talking about the stunning revelations of the excellent series by Jo Becker and Barton Gellman in the Washington Post this week. Apparently, (Vice) President Cheney is even more batshit insane and power hungry than we thought.
The particular instance here is so evil and short-sighted as to be positively delusional.
Sitting through Cheney's task force meetings, Whitman had been
stunned by what she viewed as an unquestioned belief that EPA's
regulations were primarily to blame for keeping companies from building
new power plants. "I was upset, mad, offended that there seemed to be
so much head-nodding around the table," she said.
Whitman said she had to fight "tooth and nail" to prevent Cheney's
task force from handing over the job of reforming the New Source Review
to the Energy Department, a battle she said she won only after
appealing to White House Chief of Staff Andrew H. Card Jr.
This was an environmental issue with major implications for air quality
and health, she believed, and it shouldn't be driven by a task force
primarily concerned with increasing production.
Whitman agreed that the exception for routine maintenance and repair
needed to be clarified, but not in a way that undercut the ongoing
Clinton-era lawsuits -- many of which had merit, she said.
Cheney listened to her arguments, and as usual didn't say much.
Whitman said she also met with the president to "explain my concerns"
and to offer an alternative.
She wanted to work a political trade with industry -- eliminating the New Source Review in return for support of Bush's 2002 "Clear Skies"
initiative, which outlined a market-based approach to reducing
emissions over time. But Clear Skies went nowhere. "There was never any
follow-up," Whitman said, and moreover, there was no reason for
industry to embrace even a modest pollution control initiative when the
vice president was pushing to change the rules for nothing.
Aside from the fact that this is the first inkling of the content of those energy task-force meetings, it's stunning for a number of reasons. This was all happening during the Grandma Millie summer, when Bush-Cheney donors Enron were yukking it up about shutting off the light in California just for the hell of it. "Just cut 'em off. They're so fucked. They should just bring back
fucking horses and carriages, fucking lamps, fucking kerosene lamps." Blaming a power shortage on environmentalism rather than their own unbridled greed was a logical step.
In the middle of all this, Whitman was trying to negotiate some sort of environmental giveback from industry, but the Oil Men weren't interested. They had already paid--in hefty campaign contributions--for the regulations to be gutted: why should they agree to even token concerns?
Whitman ended up stepping down over the loosening of regulations, when Bush was unswayed even by mountains of evidence about acid rain and arsenic in the water. And now, in 2007, she places the blame squarely on Cheney, who's just about due for a convenient Ken Lay-style massive coronary. Here on Liberal Mountain, our power comes from one of these nasty Eisenhower-era coal-burning plants, and it's gross. Father Ivors lives a few blocks from the power plant, and his house is permanently coated in a thin black grit that can't be good for the lungs. I can see why anyone would fight to protect the rights of people to spew that shit in the air.
But here's the problem: Whitman wants to be a heroine, that's clear. But it's too little, too late. She's coming forward with this now, when the wheels are off the bus and the war is going badly. Cheney even forgets to put on his "human" mask a good percentage of the time, just letting the world see his reptilian cyborg face. It's easy for Whitman to say , "See? I tried and I just couldn't do it!I have a conscience!"
Don't get me wrong: I'm glad she's coming forward now, but she is still One of Them. Plenty of people who marched at Nuremburg in the salad days should have been tried there later. And Whitman was there, on the dais. And she should hang with them.
If she wants to apply for readmission to the human race, she'd have to start by apologizing for telling people that the air was safe at Ground Zero. Then we can talk.